scoop - product crumbles on the scoop out and can fall apart; i wonder if my tin may have had an issue during manufacture or gotten too hot during shipping?
scent - not much to my nose
breakdown - very easy and you get a nice thick coating on the hands
application - very easily applied and spread through the beard
hold - very good hold and shaping properties for the beard
shine - i'm loving the low shine on this which is a bit of a surprise given the different oils in the product, but great for me
durability - it last all day in the beard although can get a little stiff towards the end of the day
overall this product is doing a very solid job, other than the scoop issue, point off for that, otherwise great product